Settlers Inn - Cedarburg

How can I top the best perch fry I've ever had? I opted for the roasted red potatoes as a side, which were the best I've ever had. And you can't beat their cole slaw. But then I noticed the lemon tarts in the display case, and if they taste as good as they look, my wife will be lucky to get a bite.

I absolutely love this restaurant! While everything on the menu is delicious, the standout for me is definitely their cakes. The amazing crust on their cakes reminds me of my grandmother and mother's baking. They are so good that I even served 30 of them at my wedding!

My first visit to Settlers Inn was excellent! The staff were extremely friendly and knowledgeable, providing great recommendations. I tried two different fish dishes with two different sides, and they were all delicious. The tartar sauce was particularly outstanding. I couldn't resist trying a piece of their German chocolate cake, which was absolutely amazing. I can't wait to return and sample more of their dishes.

Best fish roast! Best Tortar sauce and the most delicious raspberry squares as dessert, this is a jewel in Cedarburg, great homemade dishes!

Great local family owned and operated restaurant and deli all sorts of fresh and frozen pre made foods ready for pickup