Anthony's Pizza - Casselberry

This was our first time trying this place, and we were amazed by the large pasta stations. We ordered the best pizza, and trust me, you won't regret it. This is definitely a must-try!

I was born in Manhattan, grew up in Brooklyn and Queens, and spent many years on Long Island before retiring to Florida. In the seven years since I left New York, I hadn't tasted pizza this good! It took me back to my childhood in Brooklyn. I’m more than willing to make a half-hour trip to get to Anthony's Pizza—it's definitely worth it. Thank you for making such amazing food!

I had been a loyal customer of Anthony's Pizza for years, but I started getting takeout only due to the consistently rude and unprofessional waitstaff. However, this weekend, my family wanted to dine in, so I decided to give it another shot. It seems that Anthony's has hired new staff, because our waitress was amazing! She provided the best service I've experienced in a long time, and the food was fantastic. I highly recommend it—10/10! Be sure to ask for Jen as your waitress!

It gets my choice of the best pizza in a 50-mile radius. I'm a private pilot and I'd rather fly to Sanford Airport and hire a crew car and drive to Casselberry for their pizza over all the other pizza places that are closer. Hands down amazing pizza.

Nice lil family place to get some good new York slices. Great costumer service (thanks Jen). The price for the food that brings back memories are price less. Definitely will go again.