Papa Fattoush - Carmel

Good value for money spent. Friendly service. Gyro was alright. Dolma was alright as well. They did taste the same like the Kroger salad bar version. Not bad at all. Just expected different.Food: 4/5

Such an amazing greek restaurant!!!! Have been here so many times with my boyfriend and we love everything here. Nicest people ever!

4.5 stars!Gyro plate: 9/10 wish gyro was a bit more crisp because texture was pretty one dimensional. Flavor was great, huge portion with rice and salad. Thoughtful takeout packaging with the cold salad separate from the hot food. Spanikopita: 6.5/10 definitely have had better, this was lacking phyllo and missing that golden brown crunchiness. Portion was also smaller than expected, two triangles. Falafel plate: 8.5/10 flavorful, just a bit dry. They were generous with the tzatziki and that made this. Fries were yummy, the bartered kind so really crunchy. Hummus and pita: 10/10 so creamy, sprinkled with olive oil and sumac, perfect! Pita is more like a flatbread and doesn't really open up like a pocket, which I prefer anyway. Seating for dine in is pretty limited. We got takeout so can't speak much to the service. We'll be back!

My boyfriend and I stopped in here on our way through town for an early dinner. We ordered the platter with gyro meat and fries. We added a pita bread so my boyfriend could make a sandwich. We had plenty of food for the two of us, and we even took home a to go box of food. They offered a drink station by the door with complementary water and hot tea. Everything was really good and I would definitely come back here to eat when I pass through town again.

This is a follow up to the previous review. The service was definitely not ideal. Two of us got meals, but it went unnoticed that the third person did not receive his meal even after two reminders over the course of 35 minutes. He finally got a refund. The one good thing is that before we left, one of the very nice servers brought the food to go and using google translate (or similar), gave us a sincere apology. This place is basically for carryout food. However, I need to say that it is the best Mediterranean food I have had in Carmel/Indianapolis. We would appreciate better service, but the food is excellent. The falafel is unparalleled.