Indian Creek Steakhouse - Caldwell

I've heard a lot of good things about this place, so I decided to give it another shot with a different group of friends. Unfortunately, my experience was still underwhelming. I ordered a rare steak, but it arrived more on the medium side. My girlfriend's medium-rare steak was overcooked as well, with no pink in sight. The fries were overly greasy, reminiscent of bacon strips. If I'm spending $50 on steaks, I expect them to be cooked properly. This isn't going to be my go-to steakhouse.

This restaurant is perfect for a family dinner! We visited on a Monday night, and despite being short-staffed, the team made us feel like their top priority. The staff was very attentive, and we were seated immediately. The wine list may be concise, but it offers a good variety. Although we didn't try any cocktails, the menu looked intriguing with some unique options. Both the steaks and the burger were fantastic, and the loaded baked potatoes were delightful. We also enjoyed the excellent chocolate cake. The atmosphere was relaxed and comfortable. We will definitely be back!

So I'd never been before and since my boss was buying a coworker suggested we go. First The place is HUGE! Multiple seating and bar areas including an upstairs where we sat. The building is old and the updates have kept much of that character whichwas nice to see. It was a Friday about 6pm and I was worried the wait would be long, but we were seated right away and ourserver was prompt and helpful. I had the Dude (a steak) with fried potatoes and some beans or something in a cup. The steakwas cooked perfectly although the cup of stuff wasn't my thing and the potatoes were as expected. Everything was good but Icouldn't believe the prices. This is easily the most expensive steak house I've been to and honestly I don't feel the qualityand quantity matched up. The meal I got was 25.99 (basically the cheapest thing on the menu) and I had water to drink and with1 appetizer that was.... less than appetizing, our bill was over 85 with no alcohol. I've spent less on far better before so Icouldn't imagine spending the 50 80 or more on some of the other items there if the quality matches what I had. The atmosphereis cool, but I'll save my steak money for Texas Roadhouse.

I'm giving this restaurant only two stars because it took a long time for them to process my to-go order when I first arrived. The hostess was also quite rude. As for the food, it was exactly what the girl on the phone described—typical bar food. The French dip, along with the dipping sauce, was overly salty. Additionally, the fries could have used more cooking time.

I love the atmosphere here. That's the first thing that caught my eye. Food was very good. I had the finger steaks, a friend had the pork nachos, and another friend ordered the pork chop. All tasted excellent. Adriana was an excellent waitress! Thank uAdriana! Would recommend for a good meal and fun western charm!