Olive Oil's Pizzeria - Bethel Park

We will definitely return and have made our list of Top 5 Pizza places. Has a unique taste and a little greasy as we like it. That was our first visit.

Great service. My family and I have tried many pizza shops in the area of South Hills, and Olive Oil's Pizzeria is by far the best! Excellent food and a wide selection menu that we have tried many articles, and not one was bad. Recommend Olive Oil's Pizzeria!

As for the pizza, we decided to start our judging with a classic cheese pizza, which I think is a fair benchmark. It was fantastic—imagine the Italian Village but with less basil and better topping choices! We've experimented with a variety of toppings, including sun-dried tomatoes and gourmet options, and the feta cheese topping is excellent! The breadsticks are homemade, hand-stretched, and delicious! The cheese meals are baked in a metal tin with a mouthwatering layer of melted cheese on top—so good! The manicotti seems to be homemade, and it’s absolutely delicious, especially the spinach alfredo. The portion sizes are generous, accompanied by a side salad and two pieces of garlic bread, making for a very filling meal! Now, let's talk about desserts—they're INCREDIBLE! The chocolate cake, mousse, and tiramisu are all of restaurant quality. It’s a rare treat to have an entire meal, including dessert, delivered right to my door! Plus, the girl who usually takes my order over the phone is so friendly and upbeat. Honestly, I have nothing negative to say about this place!

We ordered pizza and breadsticks for the first time, and we will definitely be coming back! The pizza was perfect, and the breadsticks were incredible—they were topped with garlic butter! Our delivery driver was fantastic as well, bringing a great vibe and a big smile, even while wearing a mask. I will absolutely order again!

Been going there for awhile only problem I seen was different ending prices for the same item on different visits. I understand potential price increases but not three different prices in four days