Pizza Pirate - Benicia

The food was excellent; I ordered the calzone. The staff were extremely helpful and friendly.

Good solid tasty pizza, fresh ingredients, good selection of pizza combinations with medium thick crust. Fun atmosphere for kids, a local hangout with good customer service.

Read great reviews about this place so we drove out and ordered the Walk The Plank pizza and a regular salad. The chicken is claimed to be marinated in their creamy garlic sauce. Chicken tasted like plain unseasoned chicken. The garlic sauce was on the pie and had no garlic taste. It also said to have garlic on the topping, no garlic. The Italian sausage was flavorful and there was no cornmeal on the bottom of the pie which was wonderful, old school pies didn't use cornmeal. They also have a service charge for using a credit card.

We hosted a gathering in their private party room, and it was a fantastic experience. Jessica did an incredible job catering to our group, making the entire event stress-free! The food was delicious, and all the staff were friendly and eager to help.

This cozy, homey pizza place has been around for ages and is always clean! They make their food and dough in-house, which you can really taste. I highly recommend the personal pepperoni pizza and the Anne Bonnie, a delicious pesto penne with cheese (you can request it without cheese if you prefer). My friends and I have been coming here for the past 18 years, and we've always enjoyed it. The restrooms are also themed and well-stocked with hygiene products for everyone, from babies to adults. Plus, there's a mini arcade that provides tickets for fun prizes!