Fratelli Pizzeria - Bay Shore

Best Italian pizza and restaurant in the city of Islip. Tasting, enjoy your mummy?

John has been there for over 40 years and there is a reason! Much better than any high-end restaurant. You owe it to yourself to try it!!!

With the prices you would think the food is delicious and amazing. But the food is ok nothing to make a big deal over. We ordered 2 salads and a chicken cutlet with broccoli dish and each one was $27 And change. What in the world was $27 each. I?m sorry but who can afford this especially it?s a salad why the over charge for a small mediocre salad with no meat in it and hardly any dressing. This was the first time I ate here and my last. For these prices I better have some prime rib or lobster.

Great customer service, excellent food, and clean. Owners and staff are very courtious and professional. They care about their customer's satisfaction, which is a rare find now a days. And we love the pizza!

Very disappointed by this court. We often have Fratellis and very satisfied. But their delivery courts are very disappointing. Especially when he said I had to get through them? About Eats? Menu :