Bayshore Bagels Deli - Bay Shore

I've known Bill for a long time, and his sandwiches are incredible. I'll either call him or drop by, and he already knows what I want without me having to say a word. However, I really wish he would expand to a larger location that has tables for dining in. It would be great if he had opened a bigger place sooner!

I've been coming here for over a decade, and I've never been let down. The bagels are consistently fresh, and their Veggie-Cream cheese is my personal benchmark for all other Veggie-Cream cheeses. The owner is not only friendly but also works incredibly hard. I truly love this place and visit whenever I can, even though it’s a bit out of the way for me—about 10 miles further due to my unconventional sleep schedule. However, the excellent service and the quality of their bagels and cream cheese make the trip absolutely worthwhile.

Best bagel. This guy knows how to make a bagel. Every bagel, EVERY time, cooked perfectly, mixed perfectly. I employ other bagel store owners to take a ride, experience what a real bagel should taste like! Customer for life.

The owner is fantastic! He works hard and has an incredible memory! After just two visits, he already remembered my order, and it's astounding how quickly he can recall mine as well as those of the entire line of customers. They also serve the best bacon sandwiches in the area. Definitely a must-try!

Great place!! The owner always remembers my order and is a very friendly hard-working guy! The iced coffee is great as well!! Love this place!!!!