Bagel Boss East - Bay Shore

Highest priced bagel place around and they give you the least amount of filling. Embarrassing.Stood on line for 25 mins only to have a women enter, walk by everyone waiting on line, right to the front and order a bunch of bagels and had no issue because she knew some old staff member there who looks like the crypt keeper. (No, she didn’t pre order anything. It was a fresh order in the door).Avoid this place like the plague that it is.Attached is a photo of my over priced bagel. #ScumBagBagles.

One of the worst bagels i have ever had. 90% cream cheese and the cream cheese was terrible. they also messed up a simple order which i had to correct them. wouldn’t try again.

I’m a super picky eater, and ever since having covid in Jan 2021, I developed this smell/taste disorder called “parosmia” (where everything smells and tastes rotten) but I been regaining my senses back over the past 2 months I’ve been trying old foods that I used to love. I have to say hands down this was the best egg sandwich I have ever eaten in my life, even before covid! I had 1 egg over medium with ham extra cheese and mayo on a roll and omg!! So good! Def recommend

I called to place a pickup order and everything seemed to be fine. I ordered an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and asked for it to be toasted. When I get there my bagel is ready and when i opened it, there was 90% cream cheese and 10% bagel. The bagel was so chewy, it was honestly unappetizing. As i went to take a bite, all the cream cheese would fall out. I love bagels in the morning and decided to give this place a try but I have come out extremely disappointed. Never come back again.

Best Bagels in Islip!! Best breakfast sandwiches with the best sides pickle! Best salads!!! I love the staff! I order EXTRA EXTRA BACON and cheese on a roll toasted.. Where everybody knows my name! Diane the entire staff is friendly, and awesome! Been coming here for two decades! Love my bagel boss!!