Jimmy Hays Steak House - Barnum Island

We went there on Wednesday four couples and we ordered a Porterhouse for two ,it was terrible no taste at all and waiter did not care , we went again this time we tried to split a Caesar salad they charge six dollars our friend ordered fish and they split it they charge us nine dollars. Incredible what a sleazy place.

Went to a wedding reception there, and everything was delicious. The staff was very helpful and friendly.

We really had a great experience. Our food was great from start to finish. I am also glad we didn’t skip dessert, the deep dish brownie dessert was a 10/10 and I will be craving it. We will definitely be back!

Went for my birthday and couldn't have been happier. Great service, drinks and food. The beef wellington is delicious! And the calamari was also very good. Wife got the dover sole which waa also very tender and good. Will be back!

NYC Steakhouse vibe in Island Park. Service was somewhat raw as if we were doing the waiter a favor by being there. Otherwise, it 's a good but very pricey experience.