Lucky J's Pizza - Auburn

Everything about the pizza was fantastic! It tastes incredible, and the ingredients are top-notch.

I absolutely love the pizza at this place! It's New York-style, and even though I live in Cool, it always arrives hot! We usually stick to the basics and order a large pepperoni.

The pizza was tough and had a stale flavor. They didn’t follow my specific instructions. However, the jalapeño poppers were delicious. I think the restaurant should consider adding an option for customers to order dipping sauces.

Got a Pepperoni (Large) and it was good! The ingredients were noticeably fresh. The only negative was that it was poorly cut (Im being picky I know) but all the topings were slicing off as I tried to separate it- I didnt have a knife.

This is the best pizza in Auburn. If Anthony Bourdain were still alive and visiting the area, this would undoubtedly be his top choice. The pizzas at Lucky J's perfectly balance traditional flavors with creative twists. The sauce is tangy and plentiful, and every bite is packed with toppings—sometimes it's hard to even see the crust beneath all that deliciousness. Whenever I have guests visiting from out of town, this is where I order pizza from. The wings are fantastic, and while the dining experience may not reach Michelin-star status, it fits perfectly with what Lucky J's represents. It's a truly unique and wonderful gem in a market flooded with mediocre pizza chains.