Coche Comedor - Amagansett

We ordered guacamole, but the waiter mistakenly brought us salsa and chips instead. The queso appetizer was excellent, but I was disappointed with the tuna special I ordered—it was overly salty in both the sauce and spinach, making it inedible for me. The waiter did offer us a complimentary dessert to make up for the unpleasant tuna, but curiously, he didn’t extend the same offer to the other three people at our table. We also had to wait a long time before we could place our dessert order, and the water served was at room temperature. Overall, given the prices, this experience wasn’t worth it, and I won’t be returning.

This restaurant is incredible! The drinks, food, and service are all top-notch. The cuisine is authentically Mexican, not the typical American-Mexican fare. Be sure to ask about the daily specials—they're definitely worth it! You might consider it a bit pricey, but trust me, it's absolutely worth every penny.

I absolutely love the half duck and half chicken dishes, as well as the duck fried rice and plantains. The service is excellent, and the drinks are always on point!

This place is fun. The food is imaginative and very good. The tres Leche is murder. The cocktails are fun too. The ranch water was perfect for me!

An absolute amazing meal!!! Every single dish was superbly prepared in taste and presentation!!! Fav was tuna tacos, guacamole chips, pig skin and duck!!!