Critics Choice - Alexandria

Critics Choice, located in the heart of Downtown Alexandria, Louisiana, is a culinary gem offering a delightful array of hors d'oeuvres, sandwiches, dinners, and desserts that cater to every taste and preference.One of the standout features of Critics Choice is its commitment to quality and health-conscious cooking. They fry their delectable offerings in 100% cholesterol-free peanut oil, ensuring a guilt-free indulgence for patrons.The hors d'oeuvres menu boasts a variety of battered delights, from crispy string beans and beer-battered onion rings to broccoli cheese balls and mozzarella cheese sticks. Each bite is bursting with flavor and served with a side of nostalgia.For those craving a hearty sandwich, Critics Choice delivers with their Philadelphia steak sandwiches and hoagies. The thinly sliced beef cooked to perfection is served on an Italian roll with sautéed onions, mushrooms, and hot or banana peppers, creating a symphony of flavors that's sure to satisfy any appetite.Diners can also indulge in a variety of other mouthwatering options, including the Parmigiana sandwiches topped with Mom's Italian tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, and the signature Philly burger served on a NY Kaiser roll with center-cut bacon, lettuce, and tomato.In addition to sandwiches, Critics Choice offers a tempting selection of dinners, from classic Chicken Parmigiana and Spaghetti to savory Chopped Steak and Open-Faced Hot Beef. Each dish is lovingly prepared to order and served with a side of nostalgia.No meal is complete without dessert, and Critics Choice does not disappoint. Indulge in traditional Italian cannoli, New York cheesecake, or decadent chocolate layer cake, each bite a perfect ending to a memorable dining experience.Whether you're dining in or taking out, Critics Choice offers a culinary journey that delights the senses and leaves you craving more. With its diverse menu, friendly service, and commitment to quality, Critics Choice is a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts in Downtown Alexandria.

I highly recommend the Italian Grinder sandwich, it was the absolute best! Calm atmosphere and friendly welcoming staff. Will definitely come back again!

The atmosphere is very old school, the service is excellent and the food is great and they have real deal canollis. This Yankee appreciates that. A hidden treasure for sure.

Went here for the first time recently. The service was good but I’ve definitely had better Philly cheesesteaks.

Went by Critics Choice this afternoon for lunch.Yep. It’s a good choice.I love the retro feel of the place.It’s a family-run business with a waitress whom I wish was everywhere i went. (Very, very dry humor, but not sarcastic. Very kind lady)It was a quiet afternoon in downtown Alexandria and we were the only customers at that time.It’s a sandwich shop.But, oh yes, these folks know how to make sandwiches.My club sandwich on rye was exactly that.Very good meats and a smooth creamy cheese, with crisp cold lettuce, tomato, with just enough mayo on toasted rye.Skyler had a yummy roast beef sandwich with gravy (on a kaiser roll).Stephanie’s corned beef looked phenomenal.We requested an order of fries. When crinkle fries are cooked just right, they are crisp, light, and stay good even as they cool. Yes, those are the fries we had. They call them ‘freedom fries.’ And it felt like freedom indeed from all the wanna-be fries that i’ve had.And Elijah’s personal pan pepperoni pizza looked perfect. Not too dark or too light. Well cooked food for a growing boy.The hot tea we had was perfectly brewedIf you go, expect a good sandwich in an atmosphere from the last century.Leave knowing you have just had a very good sandwich with a nice relaxed atmosphere in a family run business which cares about the quality of their food and the comfort of their customers.Yep, i’m going back.PS: When i spoke to the sweet owner, she did mention that she loved collecting clowns.Actually, there was memorabilia from several different genres.A little Disney, a little of the Hollywood stars from the 50’s, a holiday tree, beautiful holiday wreath, some gorgeous dolls, and a few clowns.The room was large enough that it didn’t seem oppressive.? Vegetarian options: Although this is a sandwich shop with good meats and cheeses, i did see a veggie only sandwich in the style of a Philly cheese steak sandwich. Parking: Street parking around the corner; also a parking lot right past the stop light. Kid-friendliness: Relaxed atmosphere with room between the tables. Several food options available. Wheelchair accessibility: Easily wheelchair accessible