Gencarelli's - Toms River

Don't let the little cottage fool you. You make the best pizza we've ever had. Too far! The sauce is perfect, never burned or too sour as other pizzas. The cheese is very high quality and not greasy and the crust tastes like Italian bread. If you try her pizza, you'll be addicted to it. Nothing like here. If that's not enough, people are very nice. 5 stars just don't suffice.

They have tables outside that are wonderful in summer, but in winter they are very cold, although they have a fire pit outdoors. They are open all year round, but in the winter months it is almost all out, there are no interior seats. You also have free delivery within 5 miles. I haven't had two dinners yet, but the pizza was great

We came here after a football match, it's not a place I would have seen to go to Kettle Creek, but it's definitely a reason to go down this street. The pizza is really good, thin crust and not oily. The meatball parm we ordered was the best I ever had. The victory over it is that its outside near the water. (Byob) I could see that I gather some wines, family/friend for an hour or two in a beautiful night. Worth a visit.

Today my first order was as I heard from other people. I am a white cake lover, so I had to give him an attempt, it was really the best I had in the area!!!! I would recommend this place for your next pizza order!!! I am now a loyal customer!!!!

Everything we have gotten from Gencarelli's has been excellent the pizza's, the appetizer's, the dinner entree's !!!!! And besides the food the whole staff is AMAZING they treat you like FAMILY, Gencarelli's is the best thing to happen to our little community in silverton !!!!!