Red Maple - Shelter Island Heights

Beautifully redeemed. I admit it was strange when you came through and it was so different. but after I was there, I forgot where I was.

Blegh, cut, so-so for the total lack of personality or taste and loses 1 star for the inexplicable slow service and lack of forced. it took forever.

We had a great meal here on a Friday night in juli 2018. when they start or utter, and then my wife and I shared a burger and the apple-Fennel salad.

We had a terrific meal here on a Friday night in July 2018. If you or oysters to start and then my wife and I shared a burger and the apple-fennel salad. I had the rose but the cocktails are terrific according to the others in our party (the greyhound). Our server was terrific but I can't recall her name. She was from South Carolina and her husband was a chef there. Outdoor patio with a nice view

Blegh, average, so so for overall lack of personality or flavor and loses 1 star for the inexplicable slow service and lack of pacing. It took forever for apps to arrive (clam chowder, just put it in a bowl! . No bread or rolls to keep us occupied. Entree was slow too. Beef tenderloin tasted like it was parboiled and thrown on the grill. No seasoning, no sauce, nothing redeeming and was served underdone. Pork chop was huge and only flavor was the char. Pear marmalade tasted like jar applesauce at best. Clam chowder and mashed potatoes were the same color banana yellow. Lemon cake was disgusting. It looked like it was baked in a can and slathered with butter. It looked like something from an episode of Nailed It . It had barely any lemon flavor and the frosting tasted like land 'o lakes. Grilled asparagus and our waitress were good. Horrendously disappointing Skip it.