Vitucci's Pizza - New Berlin

Visiting the area on business, best pizza I have had in a long time!!!

Would have given zero stars if allowed. This is a carry out only and I cannot give stars for food or anything thing else. When I arrived to pickup my order I was told someone before me got my order. They offered to make new if I would wait for 40 minutes. Won't be back. Balistreris on 68th or Marty's on Bluemound will be the go to. First and last timer.

Browsed through Yelp for pizza and Vitucci's was up on my list. Very solid pizza but the calzone is what was spectacular. Very good food satisfied with what I got for the price.

I used to get Vitucci 's pizza regularly, I drove 20 minutes from my house regularly to get it, and tonight I was looking forward to it. I got there today to pick up my order to find the place is now called Basil 's Pizza and has different owners. I wish I would have known this before ordering. The phone number was the same and everything. The pizza, however is not nearly as good as it used to be. Our pizza tonight was cut into triangles instead of squares, which just doesn 't work for this type of pizza. The flavor was not the same either. It was completely soggy and mushy on the bottom, and was so incredibly salty it was inedible. No one in my family liked it. We ended up throwing it in the garbage and are now trying to figure out where to go for dinner. What a disappointment. Definitely won 't be back. We ordered from the previous place, Vituccis, regularly for years and never had a bad pizza like this. Disregard all the older reviews I guess.

Excellent! I had a custom Calzone and it was great. The crust was perfectly cooked and flavorful. I also ordered the garlic cheese bread, and it was both cheesy and garlicky. I will order from here again when I'm in town.