Tony's Pizzeria - Herkimer

We prefer thin crust pizza, and while the crust was quite thick, it was absolutely delicious. The restaurant is also very child-friendly, and the staff were wonderful.

This was my fiancée's first time trying Tony's in Herkimer, and he was absolutely amazed! We ordered a double cheese pizza with half pepperoni, and the amount of cheese was just perfect. The pepperoni was nice and crispy as well. Overall, we were really happy with our order. Thank you!

I inquired about the paprika on the fountain side, and it turned out to be perfect and delicious!

Excellent. this place makes a great cake. they use such high-quality ingredients that they do not have to hide behind the bucks of sugar and salt. these people know what they do.

This pizza is large and in charge! Loaded with toppings and crust with the cheese baked into it. It’s amazing. Also the chicken tenders are hands down the best in the area.