Gabby's Pizza - Flemington

When I worked for the harbour of flemington, I stopped for a disc and spoke with hector is very nice person he makes great pizza

Great place to stop with pizza! also the tiramisu was great!

I ordered a pizza, panini, and calamari to take out. They were all delicious! The pepperoni on the pizza was very good, and I may ask for it to be cooked a bit longer next time. I was pleasantly surprised by the high quality of the calamari and sauce for a pizzeria.

Updates. In all my pizza travels, Gabby’s is a lasting fav . My favs Chicken Vodka, and Buffalo chicken are stand outs! Must try them ! Set in a very busy parking lot off a circle, Gabby’s seems active. I’ve seen extra thick pizza there I wanted to try, but when I went again that type wasn’t ready yet . The place is small and could use a revamp. The pizza I got was Chicken parm, next Cheesesteak. Decent sized slices with ample toppings prices average for the area .I did ask for crispy which they did and I enjoyed it. The sauce was okay though I like it a bit sweeter. They wouldn’t give me a glass of water rather wanted me to buy a bottle. Bottom line pizza is very good and filling for the price but more a take out place ! I revisited Gabby’s and they had plenty of deep dish like thick slices this time so I took pics of some offerings n prices were fair .. I did finally have my thick slice. I like their crust too.. the buffalo chicken slice was well topped with chicken and sauce.. the sauce is quite tangy but good. If you like spicy try it! If you like less spicy try the Chicken Vodka my new fav there! The help was friendly and they put lots of toppings on your slice, the slice size was ample too..so you won’t be hungry or disappointed with any Pizza there! Now I go often for my favs.. need to try their Sicilian slice next! Lots of choices there ..Try some! Ask for Edwin !

Gabby's Pizza in Flemington, NJ is currently offering special deals for the 2024 Super Bowl. They have a wide variety of delicious food options including pizza, wings, knots, hot and cold subs, antipasto, and pasta dinners. We tried the pasta dinners and pizza appetizer, and both were incredibly tasty. The restaurant is open late every day of the week.