Mario's Italian - Edgerton

Good food. Our first time there. Owner working hard cooking and waiting on tables

Ordered sanwiches, beef with nothing on it, combo with nothing on it. Both came with cheese, call and told them the order was wrong, nothing happened. We threw them out because hubby is allergic to dariy and I am lactose intolerant. Did not want to spend the night in hospital. Waste of money.

The pizza was pretty good, let's start there. If I were solely judging on food, I'd say 4/5 stars. It's the best we've had in the Edgerton area...but the service sucks. We've been waiting to try this place because there are so many poor and mixed reviews. They're right! We called in a take out order and we're told 30 minutes. We arrived almost exactly 30 minutes later, assuming our food would be done or be getting close. Well. My husband sat at the front counter for 10 minutes, with staff walking by, and no one had even acknowledged him. He was finally waited on once HE asked someone for help. He then proceeded to wait another THIRTY minutes at the restaurant to wait for our food while I was sitting in the car waiting. Why not just say an hour on the phone if it's going to be that long? Also, I don't know how many carryout orders they had but there were only two tables in their restaurant. They did not appear remotely busy. Also they never apologized, never have an excuse for the time, and never have updates. The food finally came out (not on its own) but after my husband asked for an update at the half hour mark. What a joke.

My favorite place in the United States! The Panzerotti is divine. I live two hours away are always make certain to have lunch or dinner here when I'm in town.

Have been going to Marios since I was a kid, remember when Carla bought from Mario. I live out of town now but try to visit Marios when in town if time allows. Our pizza was made incorrectly, but Carla (owner) was fantastic got it made right for us. Food was delicious as always! Love her new location!