Rolling Pin - East Setauket

The Rolling Pin Bakery handled the wedding cake for our venue, and although we had heard great things about them, we had never tried any of their treats before. Because of COVID restrictions, we weren't able to do a cake tasting, so we selected our cake during one of our meetings with the venue. We wanted a burgundy piping on the cake, and the bakery reached out to us the week before the wedding to suggest changing the color due to humid and wet weather in the forecast. We truly appreciated their proactive approach, as it helped ensure that our cake wouldn’t “sweat” or have the colors run. When we finally saw the cake, it was absolutely perfect! And when we, along with our guests, tasted it, we were amazed by the incredible flavor—it was the best cake we've ever had! We will definitely recommend Rolling Pin Bakery to our friends and will be ordering from them for our future bakery needs!

Rolling Pin crafted the wedding cake for my daughter, and it was absolutely fantastic! The flavor was incredible, and it was the most stunning wedding cake I've ever encountered. The entire staff was friendly and accommodating, and David was exceptionally patient with all the questions we had. Thank you all for making my daughter's wedding so beautiful!

We got married on Saturday, September 4th, and we ordered our wedding cake from them! It was stunning and absolutely delicious! My sister is getting married in November, and she’s also going with Rolling Pin for her cake. She was so excited to learn that she’ll have an amazing cake too. We chose a marble cake with cannoli chip filling, and it was perfect! Thank you all so much!

Always a delicious assortment of cookies and pastries to choose from. The display case cakes are always beautiful and fresh. We've ordered many specialty cakes from here for birthdays and other occasions and are always impressed by the quality and detail put into the cake's taste and design. The Rolling Pin has been a community staple for ages and there'd a reason why!

We stopped by to pick up a loaf of bread but couldn't resist the pastries. On of the best pastries I've ever tried. The pastry crust was so tender it literally melted in your mouth. The peaches taste like they were picked this morning. Wish I could try one of everything.