Tony's La Pizzeria - Cedar Falls

This place is pretty good! I am from SI, NYC we KNOW what authentic NYC pizza tastes like; this is the CLOSEST here. The one star is due to it not being open all day, because I could get a 26 inch pie for $18 in the city. I would love for Tony’s to come up with something close to that as…the pizza is good, have had better yet there’s a secret to NYC pizza dough no I’m not sharing what it is. Would recommend to anyone if you’re in the area.

We were in town for a soccer tournament and looking for somewhere to order takeout for several families. Tonys was recommended by our hotel and they went above and beyond our expectations. Their menu worked for everyone in our group (including gluten free) and the food was great. We ordered food for roughly 40 people and all the orders were correct and it was ready when we requested to pick it up. Would definently eat here again when we are in town next.

I am so sad, our family loves Tony’s pizza but unless things improve, I am afraid they will not keep their customers. We waited almost 1.5 hours for our pizza, on a Wednesday, it wasn’t very busy, from what we could see. Our pizza was not made as we ordered, however our servers did proactively adjust our bill. The biggest turn off was a female cook, with red hair, who would scream servers names when food was ready, or if she had questions about an order. The yelling was not pleasant.

Was in on Saturday and the bartender was extremely rude. Rolled her eyes at me when I asked for a drink menu. Also super disrespectful to her coworkers in front of guests. Unbelievably unprofessional. I'd say maybe she was just having a bad night but when we were in there back on April 6th she was also rude- Took our initial drink order and then would not come back over to us (we were sitting at the bar). We ended up just having to leave cash on the bar as we couldn't even get her to come over to us so we could get our bills- the bar was NOT busy either, only 3 other customers sitting at the bar.

My husband and I had a civil ceremony at the courthouse and wanted to do something afterwards with our family and friends. We decided to have an after party/reception at Tony’s! This was perfect! I have many great things to say. First off, Liberty was very helpful and kind to us throughout the process and explained everything thoroughly. We had about 50 guests and rented out the back of the bar and their game room. It was the perfect amount of space. The game room was great for the kids. We ordered 10 pizzas and everyone loved them! We ended up ordering about 3 more because we started running low- but that wasn’t a problem for the staff and they made them up super quick. They helped me set up all of the decor and did clean up for us. They made sure they were there when the cake was delivered and put it in the cooler for us- this was great because it was one less thing for me to worry about! We got some great pictures in and outside the building. The atmosphere is romantic—great for a casual wedding party or date night!! My husband and I are locals and have been to Tony’s many times in the past. I would recommend them for any event or even just to walk in on a random night and have dinner. 10/10 experience